Latest Headlines
- Suspect In Cantonment Homicide Captured At Bus Stop In Phoenix
- Man Gets 15 Years For Fatally Shooting Teen At 2024 Cottage Hill Party
- Molino And Cantonment Suspects Charged After Stolen Guns Surface in Delaware
- Pace Walks Off With With District Title 4-2 Over Tate
- Free Compost Available At Escambia County Equestrian Center
- Grand Opening Date Set For Improved Beulah Regional Park
- Northview Dominates Baker To Advance To District Final Against Jay
- Northview Varsity And JV Defeat Jay (With Gallery)
- Wildness Costs Wahoos in 10-9 Loss to Smokies
- Two Highway 29 Crosswalks Coming To Century Following Fatalities, Injuries
Coffee Cup Clue Leads To Arrest Of Two Cantonment Men For Stealing $7,000 In Wire, Tools
March 26, 2026
Two men were arrested, thanks to a coffee cup, following a business burglary in Cantonment where 18 vehicles were entered and $7,000 in equipment and wire was stolen .
James Allen Casey, 46, and Michael Sheldon Lay II, 37, are both facing multiple charges including 18 counts of burglary of an unoccupied conveyance, grand theft, and trespassing.
According to the Escambia County Sheriff’s Office, the incident occurred early in the morning on March 19, 2026, at a Pike Electric supply and equipment yard on Becks Lake Road. A foreman at the facility reported that trail camera footage showed two subjects wearing camouflage walking onto the property and removing copper wire and tools.
Deputies determined that the suspects gained access to the yard by cutting a chain-link fence. Once inside, they allegedly broke into 18 trucks and stole approximately $6,000 worth of solid and stranded copper wire, a gas-powered drill valued at $500, and a chainsaw valued at $500.
Investigating deputies discovered a fresh coffee cup from a nearby convenience store on the trail used by the suspects. Surveillance video from Cumberland Farms at 392 North Highway 29 showed two men matching the descriptions from the trail camera—one in a camouflage jumpsuit and another in camouflage pants and a hat—purchasing coffee and leaving in a white Dodge Dakota. An image from Highway 29 and Tree Street also showed the same vehicle.
The vehicle was described as a Dodge Dakota with a white front end, white doors with brown or gold bottom, having a dark bed and black wheels.
Authorities later located the vehicle at a residence in Cantonment. Investigators used prior traffic stop records and driver’s license photos to positively identify both men.
Both suspects were booked into the Escambia County Jail with a bond set at $51,000 each.
Comments
8 Responses to “Coffee Cup Clue Leads To Arrest Of Two Cantonment Men For Stealing $7,000 In Wire, Tools”
The sheriffs department doesn’t like jailing sleepy criminals .
Wasted lives and wasted years. Such a shame and so disappointing. Neither one of them are very young, so this points to a pattern that their lives have been on for quite some time. But still there is hope if they will only look for it, even in prison.
Need to do away with all these Cameras. Yeah right….
Looks like Casey was arrested for theft not too long ago. He doesn’t seem to learn well from his mistakes. Maybe he shouldn’t be walking free!!
Ill never understand why people want to live a life of crime and drugs when there is absolutely nothing rewarding to it. So at the end of your life you have nothing to leave to family and nothing to show for your wasted life
Great work ESCO!
Everyone needs a coffee break .
That will teach them not to be litter-bugs!